options-comparator
Structured comparison of competing options with weighted scoring matrices, trade-off analysis, decision frameworks, and recommendation templates. Use when evaluating alternatives, making purchase decisions, or comparing strategies.
How do I install this agent skill?
npx skills add https://github.com/travisjneuman/.claude --skill options-comparatorIs this agent skill safe to install?
- Gen Agent Trust Hubpass
This skill is a collection of decision-making templates and frameworks for structured evaluation of options. It consists entirely of Markdown documentation and contains no executable scripts, external dependencies, network operations, or privileged commands. No security risks were identified.
- Socketpass
No alerts
- Snykpass
Risk: LOW · No issues
- Runlayerpass
1/1 file flagged
- ZeroLeakspass
Score: 93/100 · 2 sections analyzed
What does this agent skill do?
Options Comparator
Structured frameworks for systematically comparing alternatives, scoring options, and producing defensible recommendations.
Weighted Scoring Matrix
Standard Weighted Matrix Template
WEIGHTED SCORING MATRIX:
STEP 1: Define criteria and weights (must sum to 100%)
| Criterion | Weight | Option A | Option B | Option C |
|-----------------|--------|----------|----------|----------|
| [Criterion 1] | 25% | [1-5] | [1-5] | [1-5] |
| [Criterion 2] | 20% | [1-5] | [1-5] | [1-5] |
| [Criterion 3] | 20% | [1-5] | [1-5] | [1-5] |
| [Criterion 4] | 15% | [1-5] | [1-5] | [1-5] |
| [Criterion 5] | 10% | [1-5] | [1-5] | [1-5] |
| [Criterion 6] | 10% | [1-5] | [1-5] | [1-5] |
|-----------------|--------|----------|----------|----------|
| WEIGHTED TOTAL | 100% | [sum] | [sum] | [sum] |
STEP 2: Calculate weighted scores
Weighted score = Raw score x Weight
Total = Sum of all weighted scores
STEP 3: Interpret results
4.5-5.0: Excellent fit
3.5-4.4: Good fit
2.5-3.4: Acceptable with trade-offs
1.5-2.4: Poor fit — significant concerns
1.0-1.4: Disqualified
SCORING RUBRIC:
5 = Exceeds requirements / best in class
4 = Fully meets requirements
3 = Partially meets requirements
2 = Significant gaps
1 = Does not meet requirements / disqualifying
Weight Assignment Methods
| Method | How It Works | Best For |
|---|---|---|
| Direct assignment | Stakeholders allocate 100 points across criteria | Small groups, quick decisions |
| Pairwise comparison | Compare criteria two at a time, derive weights | Rigorous prioritization |
| MoSCoW ranking | Must/Should/Could/Won't, then assign within tiers | Requirements-driven decisions |
| Swing weighting | Rate criteria by how much best-to-worst matters | Complex multi-attribute decisions |
| Stakeholder voting | Each stakeholder distributes 10 votes | Democratic team decisions |
Weight Validation Checklist
BEFORE FINALIZING WEIGHTS:
- [ ] Weights sum to exactly 100%
- [ ] No single criterion exceeds 40% (unless justified)
- [ ] No criterion is below 5% (drop it if irrelevant)
- [ ] Weights reflect stated priorities (not just habit)
- [ ] Stakeholders reviewed and approved weights
- [ ] Weights were set BEFORE scoring options
(prevents reverse-engineering to a preferred choice)
Pairwise Comparison
Pairwise Comparison Matrix
PAIRWISE COMPARISON TEMPLATE:
Compare criteria A through E. For each pair, indicate
which is more important (mark the winner):
A B C D E WINS WEIGHT
A [--] [ ] [A] [ ] [A] 2 25%
B [B] [--] [B] [B] [B] 4 40%
C [ ] [ ] [--] [ ] [C] 1 10%
D [D] [ ] [D] [--] [D] 3 25%
E [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [--] 0 0%
Weight = Wins / Total comparisons x 100
Total comparisons = n(n-1)/2 = 5(4)/2 = 10
INSTRUCTIONS:
1. Compare each pair: "Is criterion X more important than Y?"
2. Mark the winner in the matrix
3. Count wins for each criterion
4. Calculate weights from win percentages
5. Adjust if any criterion has 0% but should remain
Forced Ranking
FORCED RANKING METHOD:
List all options and rank from best to worst on each criterion.
No ties allowed (forces differentiation).
| Criterion | Rank 1 (Best) | Rank 2 | Rank 3 | Rank 4 (Worst) |
|---------------|---------------|--------|--------|-----------------|
| Price | Option C | Option A| Option D| Option B |
| Quality | Option B | Option D| Option A| Option C |
| Speed | Option A | Option B| Option C| Option D |
| Support | Option D | Option C| Option B| Option A |
SCORING:
Rank 1 = 4 points, Rank 2 = 3, Rank 3 = 2, Rank 4 = 1
(Or weight the ranking scores by criterion importance)
Reference files
Detailed material is in separate files so this overview stays short. Read only the file whose topic matches the task; each one is self-contained. Paths are relative to the folder that holds this SKILL.md (in the full toolkit install, ~/.claude/skills/options-comparator/).
| Topic | File | Covers |
|---|---|---|
| Pros/Cons with Weights | references/pros-cons-with-weights.md | Structured Pros/Cons Template; Comparative Pros/Cons |
| Decision Matrix Template | references/decision-matrix-template.md | Comprehensive Decision Matrix |
| Trade-Off Analysis Framework | references/trade-off-analysis-framework.md | Trade-Off Mapping; Trade-Off Decision Rules |
| Sensitivity Analysis for Decisions | references/sensitivity-analysis-for-decisions.md | Weight Sensitivity Testing; Score Sensitivity Testing |
| Recommendation Memo Template | references/recommendation-memo-template.md | Executive Decision Memo |
| Vendor Evaluation Scorecard | references/vendor-evaluation-scorecard.md | Vendor Assessment Template |
| Technology Selection Framework | references/technology-selection-framework.md | Technology Evaluation Criteria; Build vs Buy Decision |
| Decision Anti-Patterns | references/decision-anti-patterns.md | 38 lines |
See Also
How can the creator link this skill?
Add the canonical catalog link to the repository README so users can inspect current installs and available audits. The publishing guide covers the complete discovery path.
<a href="https://skillzs.dev/skills/travisjneuman/.claude/options-comparator">View options-comparator on skillZs</a>