mcda-suitability-analysis
Always invoke for spatial suitability, site selection, AHP, criteria weights, or weighted-overlay work, including audits of inconsistent pairwise judgments and requests for only a final map. Covers consistency, standardization, constraints, ranked surfaces, shortlists, and sensitivity. Route travel-time placement and location-allocation to network-accessibility-analysis.
How do I install this agent skill?
npx skills add https://github.com/muend/geoai-skills --skill mcda-suitability-analysisIs this agent skill safe to install?
- Gen Agent Trust Hubpass
The skill is safe and provides methodology for site suitability analysis. It includes a utility script for AHP calculations and references reputable institutional documentation.
- Socketpass
No alerts
- Snykpass
Risk: LOW · No issues
What does this agent skill do?
MCDA & Suitability Analysis
Purpose: produce suitability maps whose weights, scales, and assumptions are explicit, consistent, and stress-tested. A suitability map without a sensitivity analysis is an opinion with a legend.
Workflow
- Structure: goal → criteria (factors) → constraints. Constraints are binary masks (legal exclusions, water bodies, slope > threshold) applied at the END by multiplication; factors are continuous and weighted. Keep them apart — encoding a constraint as a heavily-weighted factor is a classic error that lets forbidden areas score "acceptable".
- Criteria layers: each factor as a raster on a COMMON grid (same CRS, extent, cell size, snap). Resample categorical layers with nearest, continuous with bilinear; document each.
- Standardization to a common suitability scale (0-1 or 0-255):
- Linear min-max for monotonic "more is better/worse".
- Fuzzy membership (sigmoid/linear with control points) when suitability saturates — justify control points from domain knowledge.
- Categorical layers: explicit reclass table, shown to the user. Direction check: confirm for EVERY layer whether high raw value means high or low suitability (slope: low=good; distance-to-road: usually low=good). Direction bugs survive to the final map invisibly.
- Weights (AHP below, or direct/ranked methods with rationale).
- Aggregation: weighted linear combination (WLC) default; OWA when the decision-maker's risk attitude (AND-like vs OR-like) matters.
- Constraint mask multiply; classify the result (equal interval or quantiles — say which and why); sensitivity analysis; validate against known good/bad sites if any exist.
AHP with consistency enforcement
Pairwise comparisons on Saaty's 1-9 scale; weights from the principal
eigenvector; consistency ratio (CR) must be < 0.10 or the matrix goes back
for revision. Run scripts/ahp_weights.py to compute weights + CR from a
reciprocal comparison matrix (it validates reciprocity and reports λ_max).
Practices: elicit comparisons pair by pair with verbal anchors ("moderately more important" = 3); with multiple experts, aggregate judgments by geometric mean BEFORE computing weights; report the full matrix, weights, λ_max and CR in the deliverable. If CR ≥ 0.10, identify the most inconsistent triad and ask the expert to revisit it — do not silently massage numbers.
Aggregation
suit = np.zeros_like(factors[0], dtype="float32")
for w_i, f in zip(weights, factors): # factors already standardized 0-1
suit += w_i * f
suit *= constraint_mask # binary 0/1, applied last
OWA variant: sort factor values per cell and apply order weights — full AND (min) to full OR (max) continuum; use when stakeholders disagree on risk tolerance and show 2-3 scenarios.
Sensitivity analysis — mandatory
A result that flips with a small weight change is not a result:
- One-at-a-time: perturb each weight ±20% (renormalize), recompute, report % of area changing suitability class and a stability map (cells that never change class across perturbations).
- Scenario: 2-3 alternative weight sets from different stakeholder priorities; present side-by-side.
- If a Monte Carlo budget exists: sample weights from Dirichlet around the AHP vector; per-cell probability of "highly suitable" is a far stronger product than a single map.
Deliverable standard
Suitability map (classified + continuous), constraint mask map, weights
table with CR, standardization functions per criterion (with direction),
sensitivity/stability summary, and limitations paragraph (data currency,
resolution, criteria omitted). Route cartography to cartography-geoviz;
network-access criteria come from network-accessibility-analysis.
Pitfalls checklist
- Direction inversion on a criterion (the silent killer — double-check distance-based factors).
- Mixing resolutions without declaring the resampling rule.
- CR ignored or unreported.
- Constraints blended as weights → forbidden zones scored medium.
- Classifying with quantiles then reading them as absolute suitability.
- No sensitivity analysis; single map presented as truth.
Execution contract
- Workflow: define decision and stakeholders; separate constraints from factors; standardize criteria; elicit and validate weights; aggregate; test sensitivity; communicate uncertainty.
- Decision rules: use MCDA for transparent criteria-ranked surfaces, network analysis for route-constrained access, and optimization when discrete placement or capacity decisions dominate.
- Verification protocol: check criterion direction and alignment, AHP consistency, constraint enforcement, weight and threshold perturbations, and stable-versus-fragile areas.
- Failure modes: reject the model when criteria double-count the same construct, weights lack provenance, constraints leak into compensation, or rankings collapse under plausible perturbations.
- Deliverables: continuous and classified suitability maps, constraints, criteria transformations, weights and consistency ratio, sensitivity results, and limitations.
- Source freshness: consult the authoritative source registry before applying methods or implementation APIs and record the checked date.
How can the creator link this skill?
Add the canonical catalog link to the repository README so users can inspect current installs and available audits. The publishing guide covers the complete discovery path.
<a href="https://skillzs.dev/skills/muend/geoai-skills/mcda-suitability-analysis">View mcda-suitability-analysis on skillZs</a>