pilot-and-evaluation-design
Design practical pilots and evaluation protocols for industry R&D, AI, ML, analytics, LLM, banking, fintech, or enterprise solutions. Use when the user has a proposed method or solution direction and needs to validate it with offline tests, backtests, human evaluation, A/B tests, baselines, metrics, ablations, guardrails, and a go/no-go decision. Especially use after publication-grounded-solution-design or industry-problem-framing.
How do I install this agent skill?
npx skills add https://github.com/jurgendn/agent-skills --skill pilot-and-evaluation-designIs this agent skill safe to install?
- Gen Agent Trust Hubpass
The skill is a set of markdown instructions for designing R&D pilots and evaluation protocols. It contains no executable code, network operations, or security risks.
- Socketpass
No alerts
- Snykpass
Risk: LOW · No issues
What does this agent skill do?
Pilot and Evaluation Design
Design the smallest credible pilot that can decide whether an industry R&D solution should move forward.
The goal is not to prove the solution is perfect. The goal is to reduce uncertainty enough to make a responsible build, stop, or iterate decision.
When to use this skill
Use this skill when:
- a solution candidate exists and needs validation;
- the user needs a PoC, MVP, pilot, or experiment plan;
- the work must connect technical metrics to business value;
- offline evaluation, backtesting, human review, or A/B testing is needed;
- risks such as compliance, fairness, explainability, latency, or adoption must be measured.
For purely academic experiments, use experiment-design. For unclear business problems, use industry-problem-framing first.
Workflow
1. State the pilot decision
Define the decision the pilot must support:
After this pilot, we will decide whether to [scale / redesign / stop / collect more data] based on [criteria].
Avoid pilots that only produce a demo. A useful pilot changes a decision.
2. Define scope and deployment boundary
Specify:
- user group or process included;
- data window;
- product or workflow touchpoint;
- whether the pilot is offline, shadow-mode, assisted-human, or live;
- who reviews outputs;
- what actions are allowed;
- what is explicitly out of scope.
Prefer the least risky design that still tests the core mechanism.
Common pilot modes:
| Mode | Use when | Main limitation |
|---|---|---|
| Offline replay | Historical decisions and outcomes exist | Cannot measure behavior change |
| Backtest | Time-dependent decisions matter | Sensitive to leakage and policy changes |
| Shadow mode | Need production-like inputs without affecting users | No direct business impact |
| Human-assisted pilot | Need adoption and judgment signals | Human behavior adds variance |
| A/B test | Safe live intervention is possible | Requires traffic, governance, and monitoring |
3. Define baselines
Always compare against:
- current process;
- simple heuristic;
- simple statistical or ML baseline when relevant;
- published or standard method if feasible;
- human-only or human-with-tool condition when decision support is involved.
If a baseline cannot be implemented, explain why and how this weakens conclusions.
4. Choose metrics by decision role
Use four metric groups:
- Primary success metric: the metric that decides go/no-go.
- Diagnostic metrics: explain why the system works or fails.
- Business metrics: connect to cost, revenue, risk, time, satisfaction, or compliance.
- Guardrail metrics: ensure the pilot does not create unacceptable harm.
Examples:
- fraud/risk: precision@review-capacity, recall at fixed false-positive rate, loss captured, investigator workload;
- document AI: extraction F1, field-level accuracy, human correction time, hallucination rate;
- recommendation: uplift, conversion, churn, opt-out, fairness by segment;
- LLM support: answer groundedness, escalation rate, handling time, human acceptance, policy violation rate.
When the pilot pairs a metric with qualitative signals (interviews, adoption feedback, human review), design that combination intentionally rather than running two strands and stapling them together. references/mixed-methods-integration.md covers when mixing is worth it (methodological rationale, novel integrated insight), which design type fits (exploratory/explanatory sequential, convergent parallel, embedded), and the antipatterns to avoid (sample contamination, lost opportunity, integration failure) — grounded in Storey et al. (2025), arXiv:2404.06011.
5. Prevent invalid conclusions
Check for:
- target leakage;
- future information in features;
- biased labels from existing policy;
- selection bias in reviewed cases;
- seasonality and campaign effects;
- changed business rules;
- non-random pilot assignment;
- metric gaming;
- human review inconsistency;
- data drift.
If any risk is material, add a control or caveat.
6. Add ablations and stress tests
Use ablations only when they answer a decision-relevant question.
Examples:
- remove graph features to test whether network structure matters;
- compare retrieval-only vs generation-with-retrieval for LLM systems;
- compare model score vs model score plus explanation for human adoption;
- test performance by customer segment, branch, channel, or time period;
- stress test out-of-distribution months or rare cases.
7. Set go/no-go criteria
Define thresholds before seeing results.
Go: improves primary metric by X while guardrails remain within Y.
Iterate: improves diagnostics but misses business threshold.
Stop: does not beat current process or violates guardrails.
Collect data: uncertainty dominated by label/data gaps.
Use confidence intervals or repeated time splits when sample size allows.
Output format
# Pilot and evaluation design: [solution]
## Pilot decision
## Pilot scope
- Mode:
- Users/process:
- Data window:
- Deployment boundary:
- Out of scope:
## Hypothesis
If we ..., then ..., because ..., compared with ...
## Baselines
## Metrics
| Metric | Type | Why it matters | Decision threshold |
|---|---|---|---|
## Evaluation protocol
- Data split/replay design:
- Human evaluation design:
- Statistical analysis:
- Leakage controls:
- Monitoring:
## Ablations and stress tests
## Risks and guardrails
## Go/no-go criteria
## Pilot deliverables
Quality bar
A good pilot design should be small, safe, decision-relevant, and honest about what it cannot prove.
How can the creator link this skill?
Add the canonical catalog link to the repository README so users can inspect current installs and available audits. The publishing guide covers the complete discovery path.
<a href="https://skillzs.dev/skills/jurgendn/agent-skills/pilot-and-evaluation-design">View pilot-and-evaluation-design on skillZs</a>