react-router-code-review

React Router Code Review

Quick Reference

Issue Type	Reference
useEffect for data, missing loaders, params	references/data-loading.md
Form vs useFetcher, action patterns	references/mutations.md
Missing error boundaries, errorElement	references/error-handling.md
navigate() vs Link, pending states	references/navigation.md

Review Checklist

• Data loaded via loader not useEffect
• Route params accessed type-safely with validation
• Using defer() for parallel data fetching when appropriate
• Mutations use <Form> or useFetcher not manual fetch
• Actions handle both success and error cases
• Error boundaries with errorElement on routes
• Using isRouteErrorResponse() to check error types
• Navigation uses <Link> over navigate() where possible
• Pending states shown via useNavigation() or fetcher.state
• No navigation in render (only in effects or handlers)

Valid Patterns (Do NOT Flag)

These patterns are correct React Router usage - do not report as issues:

• useEffect for client-only data - Loaders run server-side; localStorage, window dimensions, and browser APIs must use useEffect
• navigate() in event handlers - Link is for declarative navigation; navigate() is correct for imperative navigation in callbacks/handlers
• Type annotation on loader data - useLoaderData<typeof loader>() is a type annotation, not a type assertion
• Empty errorElement at route level - Route may intentionally rely on parent error boundary
• Form without action prop - Posts to current URL by convention; explicit action is optional
• loader returning null - Valid when data may not exist; null is a legitimate loader return value
• Using fetcher.data without checking fetcher.state - May be intentional when stale data is acceptable during revalidation

Context-Sensitive Rules

Only flag these issues when the specific context applies:

Issue	Flag ONLY IF
Missing loader	Data is available server-side (not client-only)
useEffect for data fetching	Data is NOT client-only (localStorage, browser APIs, window size)
Missing errorElement	No parent route in the hierarchy has an error boundary
navigate() instead of Link	Navigation is NOT triggered by an event handler or conditional logic

Gates (before reporting any finding)

Run in order. Pass each gate with evidence (paths, line refs, or a one-line quote from code)—not intuition alone.

Gate 1 — Scope the route surface

Pass when: You have repo path(s) to the route module, routes config entry, or layout that owns the behavior under review (write them in your notes before flagging).

Gate 2 — Context-sensitive match

Pass when: For every issue that maps to Context-Sensitive Rules, the Flag ONLY IF condition is satisfied with a one-line rationale tied to the code; for other checklist items, you have a concrete code citation (path + line or short excerpt).

Gate 3 — Non-issue patterns

Pass when: The behavior is not covered by Valid Patterns (Do NOT Flag) for that category.

Gate 4 — Verification protocol

Load and follow review-verification-protocol. Pass when: Its pre-report checklist (and any issue-type subsection that applies) is complete for each finding you will output.

When to Load References

• Reviewing data fetching code → data-loading.md
• Reviewing forms or mutations → mutations.md
• Reviewing error handling → error-handling.md
• Reviewing navigation logic → navigation.md

Review Questions

1. Is data loaded in loaders instead of effects?
2. Are mutations using Form/action patterns?
3. Are there error boundaries at appropriate route levels?
4. Is navigation declarative with Link components?
5. Are pending states properly handled?