hackathon-idea-scoring
Score and rank candidate hackathon project ideas against judging criteria and team capabilities to select the top recommendation.
How do I install this agent skill?
npx skills add https://github.com/bernieweb3/hackathon-ai-devkit --skill hackathon-idea-scoringIs this agent skill safe to install?
- Gen Agent Trust Hubpass
This skill is a logical scoring tool designed to evaluate hackathon project ideas. It processes structured input data through a defined scoring rubric and does not perform any sensitive operations like network requests, file system access, or code execution.
- Socketpass
No alerts
- Snykpass
Risk: LOW · No issues
- Runlayerpass
1 file scanned · No issues
What does this agent skill do?
hackathon-idea-scoring
Goal
Evaluate and rank candidate project ideas against a weighted scoring rubric aligned with hackathon judging criteria and team capabilities.
Trigger Conditions
Use this skill when:
- A list of candidate ideas is available from
hackathon-idea-generator evaluation_axesfromhackathon-track-analyzerare confirmed- The team must converge on a single idea before scoping begins
- Objective comparison is needed to resolve disagreement between team members
- Invoked directly after
hackathon-idea-generator; output gates all subsequent phases
Inputs
| Input | Type | Required | Description |
|---|---|---|---|
ideas | object[] | Yes | Ideas list from hackathon-idea-generator |
evaluation_axes | object[] | Yes | Scoring axes from hackathon-track-analyzer |
team_skills | string[] | Yes | Technologies and domains the team is proficient in |
hackathon_duration_hours | integer | Yes | Total hours available |
team_size | integer | Yes | Number of team members |
weights | object | No | Custom weight overrides per evaluation axis |
Outputs
| Output | Description |
|---|---|
scored_ideas | Each idea with scores per axis and total score |
ranking | Ordered list of ideas by total score |
top_recommendation | Single recommended idea with rationale |
risk_flags | Concerns for each top-3 idea |
recommended_skills | Suggested next skills to invoke |
Rules
- Score every idea on every evaluation axis using a 1–5 scale.
- Apply axis weights when computing total score; default weight is 1.0 if not specified.
- Apply a
feasibility_penalty(-0.5 per axis point) if the team lacks skills required. - Apply a
time_penalty(-1.0) if the idea cannot realistically ship inhackathon_duration_hours. - Surface at least one risk flag per top-3 idea.
- Select
top_recommendationbased on highest adjusted total score. - Break ties in favor of the idea with the highest feasibility score.
Output Format
scored_ideas:
- id: "<idea-N>"
title: "<title>"
scores:
- axis: "<axis name>"
score: <1-5>
notes: "<rationale>"
penalties:
- type: "<feasibility|time>"
value: <number>
total_score: <number>
ranking:
- rank: <number>
id: "<idea-N>"
total_score: <number>
top_recommendation:
id: "<idea-N>"
title: "<title>"
rationale: "<string>"
risk_flags:
- id: "<idea-N>"
risks:
- "<risk>"
recommended_skills:
- "<skill-name>"
Example
Input:
ideas:
- id: "idea-1"
title: "AnchorAI"
risk_level: "medium"
- id: "idea-3"
title: "CalmDraft"
risk_level: "low"
evaluation_axes:
- axis: "Innovation"
weight: 1.5
- axis: "Impact"
weight: 1.5
- axis: "Technical Execution"
weight: 1.0
team_skills: ["Python", "React", "OpenAI API"]
hackathon_duration_hours: 24
team_size: 3
Output:
scored_ideas:
- id: "idea-1"
title: "AnchorAI"
scores:
- axis: "Innovation"
score: 4
notes: "Memory layer is novel; similar products exist but not for this audience"
- axis: "Impact"
score: 5
notes: "Addresses acute unmet need at scale"
- axis: "Technical Execution"
score: 3
notes: "Memory persistence adds integration complexity"
penalties: []
total_score: 17.5
- id: "idea-3"
title: "CalmDraft"
scores:
- axis: "Innovation"
score: 3
notes: "CBT journaling apps exist; GPT reframing is incremental"
- axis: "Impact"
score: 4
notes: "Reaches self-directed users effectively"
- axis: "Technical Execution"
score: 5
notes: "Well within team skills; highly shippable in 24h"
penalties: []
total_score: 16.5
ranking:
- rank: 1
id: "idea-1"
total_score: 17.5
- rank: 2
id: "idea-3"
total_score: 16.5
top_recommendation:
id: "idea-1"
title: "AnchorAI"
rationale: "Highest combined score on weighted innovation and impact axes; team has required skills."
risk_flags:
- id: "idea-1"
risks:
- "Memory persistence implementation may exceed time budget if OpenAI context window approach is chosen"
recommended_skills:
- "hackathon-scope-cutter"
Context Files
Knowledge Base
../hackathon-shared-resources/knowledge/hackathon-judging-criteria.md../hackathon-shared-resources/knowledge/hackathon-winning-patterns.md../hackathon-shared-resources/knowledge/hackathon-mvp-strategy.md../hackathon-shared-resources/knowledge/hackathon-common-failures.md
Playbooks
../hackathon-shared-resources/playbooks/hackathon-workflow.md
How can the creator link this skill?
Add the canonical catalog link to the repository README so users can inspect current installs and available audits. The publishing guide covers the complete discovery path.
<a href="https://skillzs.dev/skills/bernieweb3/hackathon-ai-devkit/hackathon-idea-scoring">View hackathon-idea-scoring on skillZs</a>